Mortgage Puzzles

Tracy Head • April 8, 2024

I’ve written about mortgage documentation in several columns over the years. This week I had an interesting call with several of my colleagues about trends we are seeing in the mortgage world around paperwork right now.



There are people who think that mortgage brokers are able to cut corners and have an easier time getting a mortgage approved. Ironically, I believe we are held to a higher standard which sometimes translates to frustration for clients as we are doing our due diligence with document collection.


When starting with new clients part of my conversation includes an overview of the documents we will need as well as an explanation of why. This conversation also includes a bit of an apology because I know how challenging this process can sometimes be.


“My bank has never asked for that” is something I hear often. What clients don’t consider is that their bank has a full historical view of their day to day banking as opposed to new lenders who are just being introduced to these clients.


If you were asked to lend someone half a million dollars would you do it on a handshake?


Would you assume they will repay you in a timely manner (as agreed) because they seem like good people?


Likely no to both questions.


That’s one part of the puzzle.


The other piece to the puzzle is the increasing trend of fraud in the mortgage world.


From my perspective, my reputation and livelihood are too important to entertain clients that I suspect are not quite as they appear. I explain I am very particular about gathering documents upfront to make sure we are not going to run into any unexpected or unpleasant surprises.


From time to time we come across documents that are glaringly obvious attempts at fraud. With today’s technology fictitious documents are becoming easier to create and harder to detect.

As brokers we represent both our clients and the lenders we are placing their mortgage with. I discovered fraudulent documents on one of my files recently and cancelled the application and notified the lender. 

My (ex) client was very very angry. He didn’t see what the big deal was. He went to a local branch and his mortgage was approved.

Where is the harm?


If part of the fraud includes income documents, will this client actually be able to make his mortgage payments down the road? Because he did have a substantial down payment relative to his income, does he have a sideline that isn’t declared or legal?

I absolutely agree that collecting the required documents for your mortgage can seem frustrating, and you may question why your mortgage person is asking for the weird and wonderful collection of paperwork they are asking for. Or you may question why they are asking for more and more paperwork.


Please understand that these requests are coming from the lender and we are doing our best as the middleman to help ease the process for you. Lenders want to be confident that they are making solid decisions with their approvals and are doing their best to prevent mortgage fraud.

Tracy Head

Mortgage Broker

GET STARTED
By Tracy Head March 28, 2025
In an ideal situation I have some time upfront to work with clients on their pre-approval. I like to go over what to expect in terms of both the process and what to expect in terms of closing costs when they have an accepted offer on a home. We usually talk about potential expenses like property transfer tax, an appraisal, a home inspection, home insurance, and legal fees. This time of year we also talk about upcoming property taxes for anything they are purchasing before July 1st. I think human nature is that we want to minimize our expenses and make sure we are getting the most bang for our buck. There are a few areas of cross-over where I anticipate the clients’ realtor will be speaking to them about items like the requirement to organize home insurance and the importance of a home inspection. In practice I think most realtors encourage their buyers to move forward with a home inspection because they want to ensure clients are not buying any surprises that will create headaches down the road. Sometimes clients are buying privately and are not represented. In those cases I always urge them to include a home inspection as one of their conditions. I have had clients question the need for a home inspection, particularly if they are buying a condo or a new build. Two recent examples have popped up that reinforce for me the importance of a home inspection: - We are working with a lovely first-time home buyer in the lower mainland. Her budget isn’t huge so she has been waiting and watching for the right property to come up, and for her offer to be the one chosen. The stars aligned for her last week. Her financing was approved and all of the financing conditions were signed off by the lender. We were doing a happy dance for her and had a rude awakening the day she did her home inspection. The home inspector found an ongoing leak in the kitchen that has created a soft wall which is indicative of a bigger problem. On a surface level the kitchen is beautiful and relatively recently updated. As a first-time home buyer with no family nearby our client was thrilled by the aesthetics of this condo, then devastated by the potentially expensive work needed to repair / rectify the damage. - The second situation really caught us by surprise. We have clients on Vancouver Island who have an accepted offer on a brand-new home that has never been lived in. They did choose to invest in a home inspection and we are so glad they did. It turns out that somehow some of the larger windows were installed incorrectly and this has created damage to the windows and a leak in one corner. Again, with a new build the temptation would often be to skip the home inspection. Yes, any issues with this home will be covered by warranty. Having the home inspection done and being aware of the issues upfront gives them a lot more power with respect to having these defects repaired quickly. Now that I’ve driven that point home, its important to know that not all home inspectors are created equal. Do your due diligence – look at reviews, look at the home inspector’s qualifications and length of time / experience doing home inspections. Going with the cheapest option is not always the best option.  Buying a home is the biggest investment you will likely make. Trying to save a few hundred dollars upfront may end up costing you thousands of dollars and sleepless nights down the road. Save yourself the pain and aggravation of hidden issues in your home.
By Tracy Head March 24, 2025
Annnnnnnd …. Its on!  Spring has arrived and with it comes a significant drop in mortgage interest rates. Over the last few months when I’ve chatted with clients who are renewing or planning to buy in the spring market I have said in almost every conversation that by mid-March rate wars tend to start. Regardless of what is happening in the interest rate environment as a whole it seems by the third week of March lenders start sharpening their pencils. Over the last two weeks we started to see lender bulletins trickle in advertising quick- close rate specials (ie: for mortgages finalizing within 60 days) and rate drops across the board. Today I have had updates from six different lenders and its only noon. Why is this important to you? Not all lenders have the same policies with respect to dropping their rates once your mortgage has been approved. When you go into a holding pattern after your mortgage has been approved but before it has finalized rates can change. If they go up, you are covered by the rate you have in place. If they go down, how does your lender deal with your file? Some lenders won’t drop your rate. Some lenders will drop it once. Some maybe twice. There are a few lenders that will drop your rate an unlimited number of times up to a few days before your mortgage finalizes. When I am choosing a lender for my clients this is absolutely one of the most important things I consider. All things being equal, if I can place a mortgage with a lender that offers unlimited rate float downs I will. I watch my calendar of upcoming closings and proactively reach out to those lenders to request better rates for my clients. It’s a win to be able to get the benefit of falling interest rates without having to change lenders. If you are buying a home, renewing your mortgage, or looking to refinance this is a key question you should ask your mortgage person. Find out whether they will adjust the rate on your mortgage and what the process is (do you have to request this?). At the same time, find out how many times they are able to reduce the rate for you. Regardless of the answer I suggest touching base with your mortgage person or lender periodically up to the time your finalize your mortgage to confirm you are receiving the lowest rate they have available for you.
Share by: